
HOW DIFFERENT DOES SOMETHING NEED TO BE BEFORE IT BECOMES SOMETHING ELSE?
Whenever there is a shooting in the U.S.A., the gun lobby invariably comes out and tells us that “Guns do not kill people, people with Guns kill people”. The implication being that the gun is just a tool.
As annoying, self-serving and banal as this statement is, there is a certain correctness to it, and as such, we are forced to consider that Kung Fu does not save the day; it is people using Kung Fu that save the day, just as the Gun is a tool, so is our Kung Fu.
Let’s be honest, nothing we do in training is what anyone would use in genuine trouble. Everything needs to be adjusted to fit the situation, which means we will be doing something similar and based upon our training, but essentially not the same; it will be different.
How different does something need to be before it becomes something else?
Before it becomes something we have not learnt?
How long is a piece of string?
So why does any training work?
Why does it improve our chances of a good outcome? Which it does.
What are we really doing when we think we are doing Kung Fu? What are we trying to Master?
This is going to sound like a bit of a Homer moment, but it is our old friend…
… CONTROL.
But what are we trying to CONTROL?
Let’s have a thought experiment.
Imagine a “BAD GUY” attacking you, picture it, feel it, make it real; it could be something from a lived experience, a movie, or even a fantasy Jason Statham moment.
This IS a thought experiment, so things do not need to make perfect sense.
The “BAD GUY” moves, we flash forward, poke him in the eye and knock him to the floor. Game over, we win.
O.K. Perhaps you do not buy that one, how about…
The “BAD GUY” moves, we flash forward, initiate a Tekken or Mortal Kombat-style, 7 punch, 5 kick combo. Game over, we win.
Still not happy? A bit O.T.T? How about…
The “BAD GUY” moves, we flash forward, Pak Sau and punch, latch and strike, hook kick, followed with an Elbow finisher. Game over, we win.
Most people will take this.
The first option was too simple, the second too complex, but the third was just right – the GodlyLocks choice. A big plus is that we can work on this in training.
But they all have the same chance of failing; they are the same piece of string, just different lengths.
Another piece of string is when we start at Sil Lim Tao, progress to Chi Sau, onto the Dummy, then Sparring and ultimately into a real, “Violent Situation”.
What are we doing here? What are we trying to learn? What are we trying to control?
For the first few weeks of this year, we will be looking at the work from this perspective, pretty much the same practice, just a different connection.
Onwards and upwards, 2026 begins on Thursday.














